If your child is struggling to read, you've probably started hearing names you didn't know a few months ago. The school mentions Wilson. A friend swears by Barton. The psychologist's report recommends Orton-Gillingham. Are these three different things? Is one better? And which one does your child actually need?
Here's the good news: these three are much more alike than they are different. This guide explains what each one is, where they truly differ, and how to decide what's right for your child.
THE SHORT ANSWER
Orton-Gillingham (OG) is a teaching approach: a set of principles a trained tutor uses to build lessons around one child's needs. Wilson and Barton are programs built on those same OG principles, each with its own fixed sequence and materials. Wilson is a 12-step program usually taught by certified teachers in schools. Barton is a 10-level, scripted program designed so parents and volunteers can teach it at home. All three can work well for dyslexia. The biggest difference is how much the lessons can flex to fit your child.
First, what they have in common
Wilson and Barton both grew out of Orton-Gillingham, so all three share the same DNA. They all fall under the umbrella of structured literacy, the kind of reading instruction recommended for children with dyslexia. That means instruction is:
Explicit: every sound, rule and pattern is taught directly. Nothing is left for the child to guess.
Systematic and cumulative: skills are taught in a logical order, from simple to complex, and
each new skill builds on the last.
Multisensory: children see, hear, say and move (tapping, tracing, building words with tiles) to lock learning in.
Focused on decoding and spelling: reading and spelling are taught together as two sides of the same skill.
So if you're choosing between these three, you're already choosing between good options. The far bigger risk is a child getting none of them and being taught to guess at words from pictures or context instead.
What is Orton-Gillingham?
Orton-Gillingham was developed in the 1930s by neuropsychiatrist Samuel Orton and educator Anna Gillingham. It's the original structured literacy method, and nearly every dyslexia reading program since has borrowed from it.
The most important thing to know: Orton-Gillingham is an approach, not a program. There's no single OG box set or workbook. Instead, a trained OG tutor follows a set of principles and designs each lesson for the student in front of them.
Those principles include being diagnostic and prescriptive. The tutor watches closely during every lesson, notices exactly where the child is stuck, and adjusts the next lesson to target it. If a child has mastered short vowels but keeps mixing up b and d, the lesson changes. If a concept clicks quickly, the tutor moves on instead of following a script for another week.
Because OG isn't a boxed program, the quality depends heavily on the tutor's training. Recognized certification comes from organizations such as the Orton-Gillingham Academy, which certifies practitioners at several levels after coursework and a supervised teaching practicum.
Best for: children who need lessons shaped around them, including kids with dyslexia plus ADHD, kids who have plateaued in another program, and kids who learn faster or slower than a fixed sequence allows. Learn more about how Orton-Gillingham tutoring works at Novel Tutoring.
What is the Wilson Reading System?
The Wilson Reading System (WRS) was created by Barbara Wilson and is based on Orton-Gillingham principles. It's an intensive (Tier 3) intervention designed for students in Grade 2 and up, including teens and adults, who haven't made enough progress with other reading instruction.
Wilson is organized into 12 Steps, which are broken into 63 smaller substeps. Students master each substep before moving on. One signature feature is sound tapping: children tap each sound in a word with their fingers and thumb to help them break words apart and blend them back together.
Wilson is common in schools, especially in special education and resource rooms. Wilson Language Training offers formal Level I and Level II certifications. Completing all 12 Steps typically takes two to three years or more, depending on how often lessons happen and whether they're one-on-one or in a group. (Wilson also publishes Fundations, a related classroom program for younger grades.)
Best for: students in Grade 2 and older, especially when the school already uses it and has a Wilson-certified teacher.
What is the Barton Reading & Spelling System?
The Barton Reading & Spelling System was created by Susan Barton in the 1990s to make OG-style instruction accessible to families who couldn't find or afford a specialized tutor. It's built on Orton-Gillingham principles but packaged very differently.
Barton has 10 levels, and every student starts at Level 1. Lessons are scripted, and each level comes with video tutor training, a manual and colour-coded letter tiles. Students who finish all 10 levels read and spell at about a mid-Grade 9 level. Before starting, Barton recommends a short
screening to check the child's sound-processing skills are ready for the program.
The big difference is who teaches it. Barton is designed for non-professionals, and about half of the people who buy it are parents teaching their own children. That's a real strength for families who want to do it themselves, but it's also a big time commitment. And because lessons are scripted, it can be hard for a parent to know what to change if their child gets stuck.
Best for: families who want to teach reading at home, have time to tutor consistently, and have a child who is moving steadily through the levels.
| Orton-Gillingham | Wilson Reading System | Barton Reading & Spelling | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What it is | A teaching approach | A structured program | A scripted program |
| Built on | The original method (1930s) | OG principles | OG principles |
| Structure | Tutor plans each lesson from the child's needs | 12 Steps, 63 substeps | 10 levels, every student starts at Level 1 |
| Flexibility | High: lessons change daily based on progress | Medium: set sequence, teacher plans lessons within it | Lower: scripted lessons in a fixed order |
| Who teaches it | Trained OG tutors and specialists | Certified teachers, often in schools | Parents, volunteers or Barton tutors |
| Typical ages | Any age | Grade 2 to adult | Any age, after a screening |
| Best for | Kids who need lessons built around them | Older students, school-based support | Parents teaching at home |
The real difference: a recipe vs. a trained chef
Think of Wilson and Barton as excellent, well-tested recipes. Follow them carefully and you'll usually get a great result. Orton-Gillingham is more like training a chef. A trained chef knows why the recipe works, so when something isn't turning out right, they can adjust on the spot.
For many children, a good recipe is all they need. But some children don't fit the recipe. They might need more practice on one sound and less on another. They might have attention challenges that call for shorter, more varied activities. Or they might already know half of Level 3 and get bored repeating it. That's where a trained OG tutor's ability to adapt really matters.
One more honest point: no program can make up for poor delivery. A highly trained Wilson teacher will do better than an untrained OG tutor, and the reverse is true too. When you're comparing options, the person teaching and how often they see your child matter just as much as the name of the method.
Which one is best for my child?
There's no single winner. Here's a practical way to think about it:
Your school already offers Wilson with a certified teacher? That's a strong option. Ask how often your child will get it, whether it's one-on-one or in a group, and how progress will be shared with you.
You want to teach your child yourself and have the time? Barton is designed for exactly that. Plan for consistent sessions several times a week, and have a backup plan if progress stalls.
Your child has a more complex profile (dyslexia plus ADHD, anxiety around reading, or gaps in some skills but not others)? An approach that builds lessons around them, like Orton-Gillingham, is often the better fit.
Your child has already tried a program and plateaued? That's a common sign they need instruction that's more diagnostic and adjusted to them, not just more of the same sequence.
You don't have time to tutor yourself and need outside help? Look for a trained OG or Wilson tutor who works one-on-one.
If you're still figuring out whether dyslexia is part of the picture, our dyslexia support page is a good place to start.
Questions to ask any reading tutor
Whichever name is on the method, these questions will tell you a lot about the quality of the instruction:
What training or certification do you have, and was there a supervised practicum?
Do you start with an assessment to find exactly where my child's gaps are?
Are sessions one-on-one? How many times per week do you recommend?
How do you adjust lessons if my child is stuck, or moving faster than expected?
How will you measure progress, and how often will you share it with me?
Clear, confident answers are a great sign. Vague ones are a reason to keep looking.
How Novel Tutoring uses Orton-Gillingham
At Novel Tutoring, every student starts with a comprehensive literacy assessment, and the results shape a teaching plan built for them. From there, our tutors deliver explicit, multisensory Orton-Gillingham tutoring one-on-one and online, with lessons that adjust as your child grows. Families get weekly lesson and progress reports, so you always know what your child is working on and how they're doing. Sessions are available seven days a week, before school, after school or in the evening.
Frequently asked questions
Is Wilson the same as Orton-Gillingham?
Not exactly. Wilson is a structured program based on Orton-Gillingham principles. All Wilson instruction is OG-based, but not all OG instruction is Wilson.
Is Barton an Orton-Gillingham program?
Yes, Barton is built on Orton-Gillingham principles. The difference is that its lessons are scripted so parents and volunteers can teach it without formal OG training.
Which program works fastest?
Speed depends far more on how often your child gets lessons and how well they match your child's needs than on the program's name. One-on-one instruction several times a week usually moves fastest, and an adaptable approach can skip what a child has already mastered.
Can my child switch from one to another?
Yes. Because all three share the same foundation, a child who has done Wilson or Barton can move into OG tutoring (or the reverse) without starting over. A good tutor will assess what your child already knows and pick up from there.
Can Orton-Gillingham be done online?
Yes. OG is an approach, not a set of physical props. Explicit instruction, careful sequencing and multisensory practice all adapt well to video sessions with a trained tutor.
The bottom line
Orton-Gillingham, Wilson and Barton are all good, research-informed ways to teach a child with dyslexia to read. Wilson and Barton give you a set path. Orton-Gillingham gives you a trained tutor who builds the path around your child. The right choice comes down to your child's needs, your family's time and the training of the person teaching.
If you'd like help figuring out what your child needs, book a free consultation with Novel Tutoring. We'll talk through where your child is now and what the right next step looks like.